Two state prosecutors have put the governing body of soccer on legal notice two weeks before the tournament kicks off, in what appears to be the first time a law enforcement authority has formally accused FIFA of engineering artificial ticket scarcity.
The attorneys general of New York and New Jersey announced Wednesday they have issued subpoenas to FIFA as part of a joint investigation into its ticketing practices for the 2026 FIFA World Cup. The probe centers on the eight matches scheduled at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey and focuses on two distinct allegations: that fans were misled about where their purchased seats would be located, and that FIFA deliberately withheld inventory to push up market prices.
New York Attorney General Letitia James called it a consumer protection matter. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport went further, specifically accusing the organization of “fake scarcity”: a claim that puts a formal prosecutorial label on allegations that had until now circulated among fans and journalists.
FIFA declined to comment.
Why prosecutors moved in: dynamic pricing and alleged “fake scarcity”
This is the first World Cup at which FIFA has used dynamic pricing, and fan complaints about costs have dominated the pre-tournament period. Reported prices across the three main ticket categories rose by an average of 34 percent between October and April. FIFA has made small tranches of discounted inventory available in specific instances, though these have represented a narrow share of total supply.
The joint investigation will examine whether FIFA’s ticket release schedule and public communications contributed to those price levels. It will also determine whether the organization’s conduct violated New York City’s consumer protection law.
FIFA President Gianni Infantino has previously defended pricing by pointing to market conditions. “We are in the market in which entertainment is the most developed in the world, so we have to apply market rates,” he said earlier this month.
What does FIFA risk?
FIFA’s legal risk remains unclear. Potential penalties have not been specified, and the investigation is at the subpoena stage: the attorneys general are seeking internal documents, not announcing charges. Reports indicate that California’s attorney general has separately sought information from FIFA about ticketing practices at World Cup venues in that state, suggesting scrutiny across multiple US jurisdictions, though the scope and status of that inquiry have not been independently confirmed.
Dynamic pricing models have long been normalized in live entertainment. However, at the scale of a global federation operating under US consumer protection frameworks, the approach carries fresh regulatory exposure. The tournament opens in two weeks. Remedies before kickoff are unlikely. The reputational cost, however, is already arriving.
FIFA World Cup 2026: The Business of the Beautiful Game
How brands, retailers, and the sports economy compete on football’s biggest stage.
Explore Our Coverage →
